Citation
Smith, Natalie; Knocke, Kathleen E.; & Hassmiller Lich, Kristen (2022). Using Decision Analysis to Support Implementation Planning in Research and Practice. Implementation Science Communication, 3(1), 83. PMCID: PMC9338582Abstract
BACKGROUND: The process of implementing evidence-based interventions, programs, and policies is difficult and complex. Planning for implementation is critical and likely plays a key role in the long-term impact and sustainability of interventions in practice. However, implementation planning is also difficult. Implementors must choose what to implement and how best to implement it, and each choice has costs and consequences to consider. As a step towards supporting structured and organized implementation planning, we advocate for increased use of decision analysis.MAIN TEXT: When applied to implementation planning, decision analysis guides users to explicitly define the problem of interest, outline different plans (e.g., interventions/actions, implementation strategies, timelines), and assess the potential outcomes under each alternative in their context. We ground our discussion of decision analysis in the PROACTIVE framework, which guides teams through key steps in decision analyses. This framework includes three phases: (1) definition of the decision problems and overall objectives with purposeful stakeholder engagement, (2) identification and comparison of different alternatives, and (3) synthesis of information on each alternative, incorporating uncertainty. We present three examples to illustrate the breadth of relevant decision analysis approaches to implementation planning.
CONCLUSION: To further the use of decision analysis for implementation planning, we suggest areas for future research and practice: embrace model thinking; build the business case for decision analysis; identify when, how, and for whom decision analysis is more or less useful; improve reporting and transparency of cost data; and increase collaborative opportunities and training.
URL
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s43058-022-00330-1Reference Type
Journal ArticleYear Published
2022Journal Title
Implementation Science CommunicationAuthor(s)
Smith, NatalieKnocke, Kathleen E.
Hassmiller Lich, Kristen